Monday, April 27, 2009

A nation of clerks

I was among those children who got all their education under the 1944 Education Act. A privileged generation, at least the quarter or so who passed the 11+ & went to grammar school. We experienced levels of social & economic mobility which the country has proved unable to sustain

The steps on the social ladder were clearly marked out. Even at grammar school, the majority of children left at 16, after sitting for GCE O level

Three O levels (including English & maths) would get you the most junior kind of clerical work – white collar, but probably waged rather than the status of a monthly salary

5 O levels (still with maths & English) would get you higher status – the equivalent of Civil Service Clerical Officer. You could also apply for army officer training & possibly an articled clerkship with an accountant, solicitor or Chartered Surveyor

If your parents supported you through the 2 extra years of 6th form, 2 A levels could get you a junior management post – bank, Civil Service Executive Officer. It could also get you training for SRN at one of the major London teaching hospitals, or 2-year training for primary, secondary modern or specialist sport or domestic science teaching

About 1 in 20 of the age group got to University, on a means tested grant. From the provincial point of view the main purpose of a university education, except for medics & scientists, seemed to be to qualify to teach in a grammar school

Even in those days a teacher might say that they could not teach the subject as they would like to be able to do, because they had to make sure we got the all-important O level – just as the driving instructor would later say they were teaching you to pass the test, not how to be a good driver

Some testing of proficiency is obviously essential. The trick is to leave enough room for personal interests & passions, the development of new & unconventional ways of thinking, not just efficient repetition of what the examiners already know

The problem with an education policy which judges its outcome by how many children have 5 good GCSE’s (including maths & English) is that we seem to have set our sights on producing a nation of clerks



Related post