Monday, December 22, 2008

BBC & political respect

There was an interesting discussion on Westminster Hour on Sunday about the lack of respect for politicians in this country

It is difficult to work out when we started on this path. Certainly That Was The Week That Was shocked most of us – not just politicians – by the disrespectful way it treated our leaders. It was undoubtedly delicious but we felt a bit like 4 year olds shouting Bum!

And in truth respect for politicians was hardly ever the norm in English life

A little while ago I was shocked to find myself suddenly thinking: The BBC is a big part of the problem

Not because of the alleged metropolitan liberal middle class bias – though that is undoubtedly there. And not because anyone set out to cause this problem

I think it stems from 2 of the fundamental rules which apply to the BBC – the need for balance & the need not to be seen to be beholden to the government of the day, whichever party that is

So we end up with a BBC which thinks it is its job to hold government to account, and to be equally hard on all other parties & politicians. In effect to take on the role of Opposition - to all, from its own Millbank redoubt

This has combined with a modern fad for hard, tough, and especially, challenging interviews: Why is this lying bastard lying to me?

And the taste for irony. Even Yesterday in Parliament takes a mocking tone these days, & virtually the only parliamentary correspondent given prominence in the broadsheets is the sketch writer

So even if somebody thought they could cope with all the other problems that becoming a Westminster politician entails, the thought that part of the job is putting up suavely with John Humphries at 8.10 am & rounding off the evening with Jeremy Paxman is just too much



Under every stone lurks a politician - Aristophanes