Monday, September 14, 2009

Safeguarding the safeguards

You know someone knows they have not really got a proper argument when they fall back on ‘If it saves just one child it will be worth it.’

The new registration arrangements for safeguarding children are, according to reports, expected to identify some 20,000 dubious people among the 11 million adults to be checked. That is a strike rate of less than 2 in 1000, though it will double the number of people who are known to be too dangerous to be allowed near a child. But as someone said, if you are looking for a needle in a haystack it does not seem sensible to increase the size of the haystack.

I have not heard anyone mention the problem of false positives - & these will happen.

Even if the rate of false positives is only 1 in a million 11 people will be falsely denied clearance. Even if – when – the authorities acknowledge their mistake, mud will stick; the unfortunate person, their families, will suffer.

Is that worth it, if it protects just one child?



Related post